WhyQuit.com banner. Want to quit smoking cigarettes or stop using e-cigarettes (e-cigs), bidis, kreteks, hookah, a pipe, cigars, dip, chew, snuff, snus, smokeless, chewing tobacco, or the nicotine gum, patch, lozenge, inhaler or spray?  Then you're in the right place!
WhyQuit.com   1=All   Joel's Library   Freedom   Turkeyville   How to Quit



Are cessation pharmacology quit smoking products such as NRT, Zyban and Chantix a sham upon smokers?



What All Successful Quitters Have in Common - Tomorrow there will be hundreds of millions of comfortably recovered nicotine addicts alive on planet earth and they will all have one thing in common - today they did not put any nicotine into their bodies.  A 1990 study found that 93.5% who lapsed and "tasted" one cigarette during the first three months of quitting went on to experience full relapse to smoking. It's called the "Law of Addiction."

Many master the "Law of Addiction" through repeated relapse and the school of hard-quitting-knocks. Only a tiny fraction -- probably less than 1 percent -- learn the "Law" at education oriented forums such as this. Most quit in ignorance of nicotine ability to foster relapse. Sadly, that ignorance carries potential to someday combine with other relapse factors to again deprive them of freedom.

A basic understanding that just one puff or hit will cause up to 50% of our brain's a4b2-type dopamine pathway receptors to become occupied by nicotine can be highly protective. While most walk away from trying to cheat when quitting feeling like they've gotten away with it, we cannot cheat the design of brain circuitry whose job it is to make activating events nearly impossible, in the short term (the time needed for recovery), to forget or ignore. Our dopamine pathways would again reassign nicotine use the same priority as they assign to eating food. And it wouldn't be long before we found our brain wanting, conspiring or even begging for more.

Open Lies and Hidden Truths - We nicotine addicts have been lied to by so many for so long that it's growing harder to believe anyone.  Probably the most damaging and deplorable lies of all are being told by those seeking to increase their product or procedure's market share by false marketing that seeks to convince smokers that few nicotine addicts successfully quit cold turkey, that you have to be a superhero to do so, or that it requires Herculean effort to succeed. 

Table 3 from American Cancer Society's Cancer Facts and Figures 2003 report indicating that 91.4% of smokers quit smoking entirely on their own. To the contrary, even today with smokers being drowned in a sea of quick-fix cures which include alternative nicotine delivery devices, designer drugs that mimic nicotine, magic herbs, hypnosis, Smoke-Away, acupuncture, lasers, and every gimmick and ploy imaginable, a July 2013 Gallup Poll found that more ex-smokers quit cold turkey than by all other methods combined, that only a tiny fraction of all successful ex-smokers had used approved quitting products (just 8 percent).

That finding is consistent with a 2006 Australian study which followed the smoking patients of 1,000 family practice physicians and found that 88% of all successful quitters quit smoking cold turkey, and that cold turkey quitters were twice as likely to succeed as those using the nicotine patch, nicotine gum, nicotine inhaler or Zyban (bupropion).

Sadly, organizations such as the American Cancer Society have historically demonstrated a lack of quitting method recommendation integrity in accepting millions in contributions from companies granted the right to display the Cancer Society's trusted logo on their quitting products.

Smokers Make Easy Prey - While normal to dream of a cure for nicotine dependency, we must not close our eyes and minds to actual quitting results in an arena where the most ridiculous or even fraudulent quitting scheme imaginable should statistically generate quitting testimonials from 10-11% of users at six months (the "on-your-own" quitter's own natural quitting odds). It makes nicotine addicts naturally ripe for fraud. It's also costing millions their lives. And instead of government battling against quitting fraud, most become active participants in fostering it.

Let's pretend that we concoct a new magic quit smoking product called Billy Bob's Lima Bean Butter. What's amazing is that the 10-11% who use our product, who would have succeeded anyway (unless it somehow undercuts their own natural odds of success as does NRT), will each deeply believe that our butter was almost entirely responsible for their success. No one will be able to convince them otherwise.

And we could double our butter's 10-11% six-month success rate by testing it on quitters quitting while using tools known to have their own proven effectiveness, tools such as ongoing group or telephone support, cessation education programs, coping skills development, quality self help materials (which are rather rare), cognitive behavioral therapy, and group or individual counseling. It's a way to steal instant credibility and it occurred in almost all early NRT, Zyban and Chantix clinical studies. Pfizer's five original varenicline studies (Chantix and Champix) broke records for the number of counseling sessions, with up to twenty-five. Yet marketing awards all credit to varenicline.

JAMA study finding NRT no longer effective

How long should it have taken for allegations of fraud to start flying once it was realized that over-the-counter nicotine replacement products were only generating a 7 percent six-month quitting rate, that 93% buying and trying the nicotine gum or patch were relapsing?

As I asked in a letter published in the British Medical Journal in November 2013, "Despite 39 years and billions spent on marketing, only one in 100 US ex-smokers credit nicotine gum for their success, with all approved products combined accounting for only 8% of successful cessation. How much closer to consumer fraud can approved products get?"

As suggested by the below study reviews, it should bother all of us that during the past decade we have not seen a single independent, long-term (6 months or greater) real-world, population level quitting method survey in which those purchasing and using replacement nicotine did as well as those quitting without it. Such smoker quitting surveys are inexpensive, quick, easy to generate, and successful quitters have absolutely no reason to lie about how they finally achieved success.


Table 1 from Pierce JP, Cummins SE, White MM, Humphrey A, Messer K, Quitlines and Nicotine Replacement for Smoking Cessation: Do We Need to Change Policy?, Annu. Rev. Public Health 2012. 33:12.1a 12.16

But those with a financial stake in replacement nicotine quickly dismiss quitting method performance surveys as "unscientific." What should be dismissed as totally unscientific is the randomization of smokers self-seeking replacement nicotine (not cold turkey quitters), to either nicotine or placebo devices, in clinical NRT studies that the pharmaceutical industry knew back in 1982 were not blind, as has been falsely claimed ever since.

Frustrated Expectations Key to Billions in NRT Profits - When it comes to trying to blind study participants as to their randomized assignment to either a replacement nicotine product or a placebo look-a-like, intellectually dishonest NRT researchers have pretended that nicotine is not a psychoactive chemical whose presence or absence is easily recognized by participants with significant quitting histories. The more quitting attempts a smoker has made, the more expert they became at recognizing withdrawal's onset.

Within seconds of use, nicotine generates a recognizable wanting satisfaction "aaah" sensation. Not only does it cause the brain's dopamine pathways to satisfy wanting, it activates the body's fight or flight response which perks the senses, accelerates heart rate by up to 20 beats per minute, shuts down digestion, pumps stored fats and sugars into the bloodstream thus avoiding hunger pains, and constricts peripheral blood flow which actually drops the temperature of fingers and toes by up to 5 degrees.

Pretend for a moment that you heard about a nicotine gum study at the local hospital offering participants three full months of free nicotine gum. There was only one catch. Half of those signing up would be randomly assigned to receive placebo gum instead, which contained no nicotine. Would you be able to tell if the nicotine gum you were assigned to chew was a nicotine-free placebo instead of the real thing? So could far too many of them.

If you had joined hoping to receive three months of free nicotine gum, would you have stuck around once you felt the onset of full-blown nicotine withdrawal and realized that your expectations had been frustrated? It's why replacement nicotine, Zyban and Chantix clinical trial odds ratio victories over placebo reflect expectations, not product worth.

As shown by the June 2004 Blind Spot study, anyone asserting that NRT studies were blind or that their results are "science-based" has their head in the sand. How bad is it? An April 2005 study assessing blindness found that three times as many assigned to the placebo group correctly guessed that they had been using the placebo as guessed nicotine. That finding was echoed in 2009 nicotine patch study by the co-inventor of the nicotine patch.

In November 2008, Canada's largest medical journal published my assertion that it is wrong to pretend that "researchers were somehow able to hide the onset of nicotine withdrawal symptoms from control group members, whose previous quitting history had taught them exactly how withdrawal felt (a rising tide of anxieties, anger, dysphoria, concentration difficulty and sleep fragmentation within 24 hours of quitting), and that researchers found a way to mask the reduction of withdrawal syndrome for intervention group members." I asserted that, "pharmacologic treatment of chemical dependency may be the only known research area in which blinding is impossible."

It's why such studies are worthless and reflect junk science at its worst. It's why the researcher who understands the placebo study scam/sham, and uses it to help the pharmaceutical industry make millions, is a criminal who belong behind bars. They are delaying cessation and costing lives. I submit that their day is coming, that science and history will someday declare that bogus replacement nicotine study findings indirectly killed millions.


Australian smoking cessation method rates

The only published defense against my blinding impossibility assertion has been that "incomplete blinding is a potential limitation to most clinical trials." I replied reminding researchers that "most clinical trials do not involve an attempt to improve a syndrome (chemical withdrawal) that was non-existent when the trial commenced," that "cessation pharmacology's unique objective isn't treatment of some ongoing pre-existing condition but reduction or elimination of insula driven withdrawal anxieties that arise after randomization, after the trial commands participants to commence cessation," and that "this raises unique, profound and obvious blinding concerns which demand unbiased scrutiny due to extremely dismal real-world pharmacology performance."

I've also taken the opportunity to remind researchers that the World Medical Association (WMA) Declaration of Helsinki commands that the "benefits, risks, burdens and effectiveness of a new intervention must be tested against those of the best current proven intervention" and that placebos should not be used unless "compelling and scientifically sound methodological reasons" are demonstrated. I noted that placebo is not a real-world quitting method, the expectations of those joining pharmacology trials are not shared by cold turkey quitters who fully expect to endure withdrawal, and that it is time to either adhere to WMA placebo use standards or accept full responsibility for the premature demise of quitting study participants whose human rights were violated.

Think about the benefits of approved quitting products never having to compete against the "best current proven intervention" or against real cold-turkey quitters who were educated and supported. It enables their charade to continue.

Contrary to stakeholder assertions, those wanting to quit smoking cold turkey were never invited to complete against self-selecting smokers seeking months of free replacement nicotine. I submit that if honest competition had occurred there would have been no need for these words or this page.

Industry Cover-up Hides Findings That Would Diminish Sales - Clinical cessation studies likely reflect the worst junk science ever perpetrated upon humans. Shamefully, true science has turned its collective head as those with a stake in nicotine sales were allowed to redefine "quitting" so as to label a natural insecticide "medicine," to term its use "therapy," and, in declaring success, compare those who had quit using it to those who had not.

But who has greater culpability, those who have knowingly engaged in dopamine pathway stimulation junk science, or government agencies and health organizations which continue to hide critical findings that would allow smokers to make informed, intelligent and reasoned decisions?

What percentage of over-the-counter NRT users are still not smoking at six months? Wouldn't this be an important fact to know if planning to quit? I challenge you to locate an answer at any government, health or commercial website advocating NRT use. A March 2003 study, conducted by NRT industry consultants, combined and average all seven over-the-counter NRT patch and gum studies and found that only 7% of study participants were still not smoking at six-months.  It's actually worse than 7%. The same industry consultants published a November 2003 study which found that as many as 7% of successful gum quitters and 2% of patch users were still hooked on the gum or patch at six months.  Obviously these were two entirely different studies but even so the math for nicotine gum (7-7=0) screams deceit.

Seventy percent of surveyed U.S. smokes say they want to quit and the vast majority have now attempted quitting with pharmacology and failed. Millions have now failed at multiple NRT attempts. How many priceless periods of quitting confidence does the average smoker have in them before joining the 50% of all adult smokers losing an average of 13-14 years of life? What is a quitter's odds of success during a second or subsequent NRT attempt? Is it important information? As with the 7% OTC NRT six month rate, try to locate any government or health organization quit smoking website that tells quitters their odds during a second nicotine patch attempt. I've been unable to locate any.

The pharmaceutical industry, government health agencies and health non-profits have known since as early as 1993 that if you have already tried quitting once with the nicotine patch that your odds during a second attempt drop to near 0%.  Yes, unlike cold turkey, where the odds of discovering the power of one puff (or hit) of nicotine to foster full relapse actually increase with each failed attempt, the repeat NRT quitter's odds of success dramatically decline with subsequent use.

What lesson is eventually learned by repeat use of the very chemical we're dependent upon? Look closely at quitting attempt representations at sites advocating NRT use. If NRT success rates actually do decline with repleat NRT use, shouldn't use of what are primarily cold turkey quitting attempt statistics, in order to create false expectations for repeat NRT use, be considered criminal? Toying with the very chemical we were dependent upon has interfered with natural self-discovery of the Law of Addiction through the school of hard-quitting-knocks and substantially contributed to stalling the decline in the U.S. smoking rate.

We now know that at least 36.6% of all current nicotine gum users are chronic long-term users of greater than 6 months ( Tobacco Control, Nov. 2003).  Unlike the gum, which traps some nicotine, the nicotine lozenge fully dissolves, delivering up to 25% more nicotine. We have absolutely no reason to believe that the number of quitters getting hooked on the cure isn't at this moment climbing higher. Researchers continue to ignore long-term NRT addict concerns about increases in tolerance and losing their hair and teeth.

If you are able to get your brain's dopamine, adrenaline and serotonin pathways adjusted to again functioning without nicotine at the exact same time that you are feeding them nicotine, you should be extremely proud of yourself because you are in fact a superhero.  But if you are among the 93 out of 100 first time OTC NRT users who quickly relapse, or among the nearly 100% who fail during a second or subsequent attempt, do not grow discouraged as you are in some wonderful, wonderful company.

Chantix and Champix (varenicline) Killing Quitters -

I've entitled by primary Chantix/Champix article, "Will Chantix really help me quit smoking?" and assert that the odds are "not Click this link to watch a 4/1/08 FDA video clip discussing Chantix risk factorsgood," probably in the neighborhood of 1 in 11 of being able to quit for one year if used as a stand-alone quitting product without any accompanying education, counseling or support. There's simply no nice way to say it. As shown at the below links, smokers using a chemical in order to try and save and extend their life are instead being killed by it. It makes no sense.

Worse yet, when examining both 6 month and 1 year "7-day point prevalence abstinence rates (determined by asking participants whether or not they had smoked a cigarette within the prior 7 days), in the only head-to-head competition between Chantix and NRT, a 2008 nicotine patch study, Pfizer's researchers were forced to report that there "were no significant differences" between Chantix and nicotine patch users at either 6 months (varenicline 38.6% vs. patch 34.1%) or one year (varenicline 34.8% vs. patch 31.4%).

Nicotine addicts are not breaking free because of weeks or months spent toying with chemicals that stimulate brain dopamine pathways but in spite of having done so. Our core dreams and desires for freedom are not altered by standing in front of any weaning product or even Billy Bob's Lima Bean Butter. It is "you" who'll do the work. As long as you remain obedient to the Law of Addiction, locate a source of ongoing support and keep your day #1 dreams vibrant and alive long enough to allow you to again become entirely comfortable within nicotine-free skin, you'll eventually be free to award full credit to any product or procedure you desire. But the truth is, the glory will be 100% yours!

It should be noted that many of the below NRT studies focus almost exclusively on over-the-counter (OTC) replacement nicotine products used as stand alone recovery tools. Obviously, the 7% OTC NRT six-month rate should increase when used in conjunction with any program having a support, education or counseling component, depending upon the intensity and quality of the program. But with an almost complete absence of NRT compliance programs in U.S. cities, and less than 1% of all quitters turning to the Internet for cessation assistance, the below studies accurately reflect how almost all replacement nicotine products are today being used.

Keep in mind that a 7 mg. nicotine patch delivers the nicotine equivalent of smoking seven cigarettes a day. In the end, all drug addicts who successfully recover must give-up their drug. In fact, all successful quitters eventually go cold turkey. At that moment the rule becomes the same for all ... no nicotine just one day at a time ... Never Take Another Puff, Dip, Suck, Chew or Patch!



Studies and Insights that NRT, Zyban
& Chantix Profiteers Will Never Share


October
2013
August
2013
August
2012
March
2012
February
2012
December
2011
November
2011
June
2011
January
2011
January
2011
November
2010
March
2010
December
2009
December
2008
November
2008
October
2008
June
2008
June
2008
May
2008
May
2008
May
2008
March
2008
February
2008
February
2008
October
2007
March 2007
2007
February
2007
February
2007
February
2007
February
2007
February
2007
December
2006
October
2006
October
2006
August
2006
May
2006
April
2006
February
2006
December
2005
January
2005
June
2004
April
2004
November
2003
October
2003
July
2003
June
2003
March
2003
September
2002
May
2002
April
2002
November
2000
January
2000
April
1993
1986
1984




Recent Bupropion Studies
(Zyban or Wellbutrin)

Looking back to the early studies, there is no debate but that bupropion use demonstrates an early advantage over placebo of roughly 10-15 percentage points at six months. What is of concern is that its six-month advantage gradually diminishes over time with a number of studies now reporting little or no difference between bupropion and placebo group performance rates between one and two years. But why?

It would seem that ending bupropion use somehow brings with it its very own adjustment period with increased risks of relapse. We know that it elevates dopamine levels -- to a much lesser degree than nicotine -- along with elevating serotonin and norepinephrine. Although for many quitters it clearly takes the anxiety edge off of early withdrawal, it is probably important to appreciate and anticipate that there is likely additional brain pathway re-sensitization (and the need for conscious adjustment to that re-sensitization) that will be necessary once bupropion use ends.

Although adverse reaction risks associated with bupropion use are very real, including a 1 in 1,000 risk of seizures, they pale in comparison to the continuing risks associated with ongoing dependency upon smoking nicotine. Do not let anyone scare you into believing that any medication risk could possibly come close to the 50% risk of death associated with your chemical addiction to smoking nicotine.

That being said, it is also important to note that should you start taking bupropion and be forced to stop due to an adverse reaction, there is absolutely no reason why you will not be able to continue to remain nicotine free. Yes, for some it takes the edge off but edge or not the next few minutes are all that matter and each will be entirely do-able!

If you should give bupropion a try, be sure and read the prescribing information sheet that comes with it, stay alert for the adverse reactions listed and if at all concerned immediately pick-up the telephone and contact your physician or pharmacist.



May
2006
February
2006
November
2005
September
2004
September
2004
August
2004
February
2004
October
2003
2003
January
2003
July
2002
September
2001
June
2001



Hypnotism and Acupuncture

The traveling hypnotist and your local acupuncturist will never tell you that all objective independent study evidence to date has found both procedures ineffective in helping smokers quit.  Why?  They will not share objective independent study findings because they know just how badly you want to break free and know that you're willing to pay hard earned money for a quick and painless cure.

That being said, the absence of current objective evidence does not mean that some practitioner might not eventually develop a procedure that is in fact effective. But ask yourself, if you developed a quitting procedure that was highly effective wouldn't you want to have it either independently evaluated or open and transparent for all eyes to evaluate for themselves?

It is also important to note that the most worthless product or procedure on earth can be given the illusion of effectiveness by being combined with tools that are effective. Education, understanding, new coping skills, counseling, physician involvement, group or individual support from ex-smokers, friends or society, financial incentives, and bupropion (Zyban/Wellbutrin) have all demonstrated varying degrees of "real-world" advantage. When combined with any product or procedure they have the ability to make that product or procedure look vastly superior to its true merits if any).


"How Effective is Hypnosis?"

"How Effective is Acupuncture?"




Ten Free, Healthy and Productive Quitting Aids

There is only one quitting aid that can 100% guarantee success and it is you! This can be the most amazing temporary journey of adjustment and healing you have ever made if you will only expand your mind to believe that encountering and overcoming each and every challenge is a very necessary part of a full and complete recovery. The real quitting took place on the day that nicotine took command and control of your mind, quickly suppressing all memory the amazing sense of inner quiet and calm you once called home. Stop being afraid. Fully embrace your journey home to where neurochemical flow in response to life not nicotine's two-hour blood serum chemical half-life!

1.
A detailed list of your reasons for quitting.
2.
An understanding of how our "reasons for quitting" serve as the wind beneath the recovery wings of every successful ex-smoker.
3.
An educated mind that understands the core principles of chemical dependency upon nicotine and how to break its grip so that true healing can at last begin.
4.
A no-nonsense nicotine-free source of rock solid motivational support that will stay in your corner for at least 90 days (a dedicated friend, a local support group, a telephone quitline committed to nicotine cessation, or an online forum such as Freedom from Nicotine).
5.
Three days of acidic fruit juices to counter low blood sugar symptoms and accelerate depletion of the alkaloid nicotine within your body.
6.
A sense of recovery patience that abandons the big bite concept of quitting forever and instead embraces a manageable and do-able one day at a time recovery philosophy that celebrates each hour, challenge, and day of healing and freedom as the complete victory each reflects.
7.
8.
Slow deep dopamine generating breaths into the bottom of both lungs, a nice cool glass of refreshing dopamine generating water, and taking a brief moment to feel a sense of real pride and dopamine generating accomplishment as your healing survives yet another less than three minute crave episode and you move one wonderful step closer to again comfortably engaging life as you!
9.
A big big dopamine generating hug, if available, or a bit of self-love or self-like if not.
10.
Always remembering the one rule that if followed provides a 100% guarantee of permanent success to each of us- no nicotine today, Never Take Another Puff!


Yes you can!






WhyQuit's basic "how to quit smoking" video

Watch 200+ additional free video stop smoking lessons






Read our free quitting e-books

Click to learn more about Joel's free e-book before downloading it              Click to learn more about John's free e-book before downloading it.

Read both and watch knowledge destroy quitting anxieties!






Visit WhyQuit and learn more about smart turkey quitting


Learn More About Smart Turkey Quitting

  • WhyQuit.com's coffin bannerWhyQuit.com - WhyQuit is the Internet's oldest forum devoted to the art, science and psychology of cold turkey quitting, the stop smoking method used by the vast majority of all successful long-term ex-smokers. Left to right, WhyQuit is organized under three headings: (1) Motivation, (2) Education and (3) Support.
  • "Never Take Another Puff" - Imagine a free 149 page stop smoking ebook that's registered more than 4 million downloads and was written by a man who has devoted 40 years, full-time to helping smokers quit. Never Take Another Puff (NTAP) was authored by Joel Spitzer, the Internet's leading authority on how to stop smoking cold turkey. It is an insightful collection of almost 100 articles on every cessation topic imaginable.
  • "Freedom from Nicotine - The Journey Home" - Written by John R. Polito, a former 30-year heavy smoker and WhyQuit's 1999 founder, Freedom from Nicotine (FFN) is a free nicotine dependency recovery book that documents the science underlying nicotine dependency and successful cessation. Visit Turkeyville, Facebook's most popular quit smoking support group!Whether hooked on cigarettes, e-cigarettes (e-cigs), bidis, kreteks, a pipe, hookah or cigars, on dip, chew, snuff or snus, or on the nicotine gum, lozenge, spray, inhaler or patch, FFN provides a comprehensive yet easy to follow road-map to freedom from nicotine.
  • Turkeyville - Visit Turkeyville, Facebook's most popular quit smoking support group. The group's primary focus is the first few days and helping new quitters get started. Yes you can!
  • Joel's Library - Joel's Library is home to Joel Spitzer's "Daily Quitting Lesson Guide." The Guide walks new quitters through the first two weeks of smoking cessation, recommending daily videos to watch and articles to read. Joel's Library is also home to more than 100 original short stop smoking articles, to his free ebook Never Take Another Puff, and to his collection of more than 200 video stop smoking lessons.
  • Nicotine Addiction 101 - WhyQuit's guide to understanding nicotine dependency.
  • Freedom's small link banner Freedom - Looking for a deadly serious and highly focused education oriented support group? Home to Joel Spitzer, Freedom is the Internet's only 100% nicotine-free peer messageboard support forum. Explore Freedom's hundreds of thousands of archived member posts on how to quit smoking.
  • Nicotine Cessation Topic Index - An alphabetical subject matter index to hundreds of nicotine cessation support group discussions, article and videos.
  • 40 Quitting Tips - Key cold turkey nicotine cessation tips on how to stop smoking, vaping, chewing or sucking nicotine into your body and bloodstream.

Knowledge is a Quitting Method!


WhyQuit's small banner



© WhyQuit.Com 2014 - Last updated January 7, 2014 by John R. Polito